Suárez vs Messi and Cristiano (and vs Higuaín)

Luis Suárez scored 40 goals in the 2015/16 Liga in 35 games. Absolutely amazing! Inevitably, comparisons with Messi and Cristiano, the best goalscorers of the last years, have emerged. In order to understand how their goalscoring numbers compare I made a small chart including not just these 3 forwards but all the best goalscorers of Europe’s Top 5 Leagues.

I have considered individual seasons of those players who have managed to score 10 or more league goals in a single season in the Top 5 Leagues during the last 7 seasons. This condition is fulfilled in 723 occasions. Obviously, some players feature multiple times in this list, since they have managed to score 10+ goals in multiple seasons. For these players I calculated the ‘goals/90min’ ratio and then ranked them according to this parameter, from the 1st (Messi; Liga 2012/13; 1.566 goals/90min) to the 723rd (Hugo Rodallega; Premier League 2009/10; 0.271 goals/90min). In the below chart I have plotted Suárez’s, Messi’s, Cristiano’s and Higuaín’s seasons, starting from their personal best to their worst. Why Higuaín is here? Because I noticed that he is the closest to Messi and Cristiano.


It goes without saying that lower in this chart the better. What we see here is that Suárez’s 2015/16 season (his best) is among the best that we have witnessed. He had 1.143 goals/90min, a ratio that has been achieved only 10 times in the last seven seasons (considering all players in the Top 5 Leagues). But…that is just one season. After this seasons he becomes ‘normal’. To simply put it, Suárez is nowhere near Messi and Cristiano. In order to be comparable with them, he needs at least 2-3 other seasons like this. This is not to under valuate Suárez but just to emphasize that what Messi and Cristiano have done in terms of goalscoring season after season is something so difficult to be repeated.

Higuaín deserves a special mention here. Look at his line…absolutely amazing. He has 3 seasons in ‘Messi and Cristiano level’ and his other ‘worse’ seasons are pretty consistent too. He is probably one of the most consistent and of course underrated goalscorers of the last years.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: